The wiki for tag "produce" https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:produce mentions that "In some cases the key produce=* is used with shop=farm". Looking at taginfo the combinations (= additional tags) with tag shop=farm https://taginfo.openstreetmap.ch/tags/shop=farm#combinations only mentions "produce"
Anyhow: I would not go into the details of how far a product is being processed and where it is exactly produced.
For farm stores I also propose Key product:
shop=farm product=milk;apple;honey;meat
That's how I adapted it in the PotM CH too, too for the moment: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/DE:Project_of_the_month_Switzerland#PotM...
--Stefan
Am Fr., 18. Nov. 2022 um 18:53 Uhr schrieb Marc M. marc_marc_irc@hotmail.com:
Le 18.11.22 à 15:54, Christian Egli a écrit :
So my entries so far all use the product tag like product=bread;fruit
Thoughts, comments?
there is no product=fruit, fruit is unprocessed/raw food.
- unprocessed/raw food :
farmland, orchard, farms produce grain, vegetables, fruit, livestock and what is produced by animals (honey, eggs, milk) -> produce=vegetable;fruit;beef;egg;honey;milk; potato
- processed products :
food factories or artisanal "factories" transform these unprocessed raw foods into other (processed) products such as mead, cheese, Chips product=hydromel;cheese;chips
- selling
in a shop=supermarket or shop=farme, these products are sold -> vending=*
- the grey zone: this only concerns products that are not very little
processed products : e.g. a farmer who makes jars with his vegetables, it is probably acceptable to put produce=* on the landuse=farmyard or on the building. if he makes jam, it is a processed product which also requires a processed product (sugar), it is the grez zone
some real examples that I have dealt with or plan to deal with:
- a farmer has an orchard. he sells apples and apple alcohol. (he
doesn't produce the alcohol, the distillery does) -> produce=apple for the landuse=orchard and on vending=apple;alcohol on the shop=farm. on the distillery product=alcohol
- a beef farmer: produce=beef on the dedicated part of his farm.
vending=beef on his shop=farm
Regards, Marc _______________________________________________ talk-ch mailing list talk-ch@openstreetmap.ch http://lists.openstreetmap.ch/mailman/listinfo/talk-ch