Am 28.10.2017 um 17:20 schrieb marc marc:
Hello,
Le 28. 10. 17 à 16:28, Simon Poole a écrit :
Do not update them in OSM, report changes to Mobility directly. jetzt treffen sie aber definitiv nicht mehr
if I understand well there was a shift mechanism from mobility to osm update from mobility doesn't exit anymore ? (and why ?) if yes, +1 for removing notes
As said, the imports were a long time ago and we've learnt a lot since then. The basic problem was that (location) improved data in OSM was getting overwritten by inferior data from mobility.
The reasonable way of using data from mobility now, would be to use it for QA (we are missing a couple of 100 locations, which likely are mostly in car parks (buildings) and to highlight differences, for example like we do with public transport stops (DIDOK). Mobility actually has a trivial number of locations in comparison so getting back to 100% coverage could likely be done in a handful of weeks -if- we knew where the differences are.
But AFAIK the mobility data is not on open terms which makes using it even for QA without explicit permission impossible . While I've had no contact directly with them, various people have tried to contact them with no success or even response over the years so I'm not sure if it is even worth the trouble to try again.
The above is however orthogonal to the question I'm asking :-).
Simon