Hi,
On Thu, Jun 09, 2011 at 11:22:59AM +0200, Beni Buess wrote:
On 09. 06. 11 05:25, Simon Poole wrote:
And, what is the magic that has to be added to a stop to make it "green"?
I I understand well, if the Didok import was the last thing happened to the node, it's orange or red. To make it green, go onsite, check if the node is OK, edit it, done.
yes, thats it. As Sarah described in the swiss taginfo thread:
user=DidokImportCH, version=1 red added with Didok, needs resurvey user=DidokImportCH, version>1 orange added by user, changed by Didok, probably ok user<>DidokImportCH green resurveyed, ok
there was no discussion on whether we should add the new tagging schema (1) to the stops, if we touch them. If we do, i think we should *at least* place the bus stops ON the way with public_transport=stop_position. if the stop ist not exactly on the same place for both route directions, 2 nodes should be placed. and then, there is more about the public transport feature, but read it yourself.
My personal opinion in this: for simple bus stops, we should stick with the old schema. That is, put a highway=bus_stop node where the pole is and that's it. (For the Didok data, it means indeed to duplicate the imported nodes most of the time because there are two poles per stop.) For the more complicated stops or for micromapping train stations, use the new schema. Just make sure that one node remains that also has the traditional tags, so renderers don't get confused.
Gruss
Sarah